Carle Place: History, Parks, and Diners

Carle Place combines specific historical landmarks with named parks and its own diner tradition. When planning your trip, you can focus on local history, the baseball connection of two facilities, or the different dining options. The sections below organize these destinations by topic and give their street locations where provided.

Local History and Architecture

An early chapter in the area’s history dates to 1835, when Silas Carle purchased 220 acres of farmland in Carle Place and had a country house built there for himself and his wife. A house that became known to locals as “The Carle Place” still stands at the corner of Jericho Turnpike and Old Westbury Road. The year, acreage, and intersection anchor this part of the story to specific local landmarks.

Another historic landmark is Saint Mary’s Chapel, also known as Saint Mary’s Episcopal Church. It is located on Rushmore Avenue between Roslyn Avenue and Glen Cove Avenue and has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places since 2005. The chapel adds a distinct architectural and historic-preservation focus to the story of the country house. Its alternate name helps identify both names as referring to the same church.

Parks and Baseball Connections

The exact names help distinguish the different locations associated with parks and sports. Charles Fuschillo Park is at the intersection of Carle Road and Broadmoor Lane. The Eighth & Asbury Little League Fields are at 8th Avenue and Asbury Avenue. A 2013 recreation guide lists baseball at both locations. This links two distinct, named facilities through a shared sports connection, while their listed street locations differ.

Carle Place Veterans Memorial Park adds another park name to the area. A 2009 document lists the property in Carle Place as Carle Place Veterans Memorial Park, a property designated as a park. The local listings therefore include a park at a named intersection, Little League fields with a baseball connection, and a Veterans Memorial Park property. If you are interested in baseball, the two facilities listed for the sport are clearly named; for the memorial park, the park designation is the main focus.

Diners on Old Country Road

For a meal break, the two diners offer specific and distinct dining options. Carle Place Diner is a classic diner at 151 Old Country Road. It has served Long Island for more than 30 years and offers breakfast, sandwiches, entrees, desserts, and cocktails. Thomas’s Ham & Eggery Diner is at 325 Old Country Road in Carle Place. It has been in business for more than 75 years and offers breakfast dishes, freshly baked muffins, cookies, and cakes.

Both diners serve breakfast. Among the other items mentioned, Carle Place Diner features sandwiches, entrees, and cocktails, while Thomas’s stands out for its freshly baked muffins, cookies, and cakes. You can distinguish the two establishments by their respective listed menus rather than grouping them solely under the shared diner label.

Discover more destinations: Jericho, Woodbury, Valley Stream, Oyster Bay, Massapequa, Hicksville, Inwood, Plainview.

For the broader travel overview: Nassau.